An interesting story has just reached my ears that has made my brain jump into overdrive and my emotional roller-coaster speed up about 50 percent. Perhaps by now you've already heard about the protesters showing up at a Switchfoot concert. If you haven't, then here's the gist of it. A group of folks from a nearby church showed up with signs and megaphones to protest the band's use of rock music with christian lyrics. They claimed that Switchfoot music won't be in Hell, just Switchfoot fans. Wow. (Apparently God's saving power only extends so far. It can save us from our filthy lives and the death we deserve, but it can't overcome the type of music I listen to. *sarcasm*) But here's something else. Jon Foreman (front-man of Switchfoot) responded by handing out water bottles to the protesters and urging concert attendees to respond in a loving, God-honoring way. Again, wow!
Now, I'm not a Switchfoot fan. I don't even listen to Switchfoot, except when they come on the radio--and even then, I don't really like their music. That's just me. So by now, you're probably wondering why I really care about this. Well, to be honest, I had intended for quite some time to write a blog post about my theory on music, and then this came up. First of all, I respect the way Jon Foreman handled this situation. I may not like his music, but I gotta say, he was living out Jesus' commandment to turn the other cheek that night (Matt. 5:39-44), and I feel the need to recognize that. Second, it really fit with what I wanted the post to be about.
And so, with this interesting incident in mind, let's move on to the subject of music in general.
I know I've already written a couple of blog posts on this already, but having a wide range of music tastes, having written quite a bit of music myself in multiple styles, and just studying music in general, there are quite a few things I've noticed about it. And it seems like this theory in my head just makes more and more sense the more I study it.
Think about this. Music is something that is very hard to explain. It stands out in contrast to this shadowy, corrupted world. It's also everywhere we go--and I don't mean just in stores, cars, homes, and (shudder--elevators). Every sound we hear is a note. Say a single-syllable word. Say it again, only this time, draw it out a bit. Congratulations, you're now singing a note. (Maybe several, depending on your inflection. Sarcasm tends to create a myriad of notes each syllable). Our very speech is music. We've all heard how a particular song has really touched someone's heart, even had our own hearts touched by music. Music is a very powerful thing. Perhaps, this is why our words have such an effect. Because when we speak, we are in fact speaking music into someone's life. This also brings up another neat thought about God speaking the universe into being. Our world, possibly, was formed by music. God's music. My only conclusion to this is that music is straight from God, Himself.
Which now raises a few questions. What then, is God-honoring music? How is there music that glorifies sin and even Satan. Well if my theory is true, God didn't just bring the world into existence with a note, but also with a word. You see, it was the word that made all the difference. Light appeared Because God said, "Let there be light." (Gen.1:3) Also, God has always been more concerned about our heart, rather than the appearance. Even in the outward law of the Old Testament, there are words of our hearts being circumcised. (Deut. 30:6) Fast forward to when Jesus walked the earth, and he constantly brings the commandments into the perspective of what goes on in the heart. So, I believe it is the heart and words that determines whether or not it is God-honoring music. (And I don't believe that means having to mention God's name every other line--but let's not get into that right now.)
Next question. What about the music styles then? Are there certain styles that have been created by man and Satan that should never be mixed with lyrics about God? OK... This is where it gets exciting for me. As mentioned before, I've studied a lot of music. And not just christian music. Yeah, I'm the kid that you don't want to take to a store playing modern music to hang out, because I'll end up spacing out listening to the music and taking down notes in my head. ("Oh, sorry! What? I was listening to the music. Hey! Know who this is?") Now here's what I've noticed. Each style has a theme that, interestingly enough, doesn't change, whether it's a christian or mainstream artist using it. Let me break down a few genres, showing how the themes change and yet, stay the same, from mainstream to christian.
Pop:
OK. We've ALL heard at least one mainstream pop song. So this is going to be pretty easy, since it's the most popular style in both music realms. The style really lends itself to happy beats and melodies, as well as a few reflective ballads. The main theme is usually about love.
Mainstream: Thousands upon thousands of love songs exist in the mainstream pop arena. I don't even think we have enough fingers or toes to count the many love stories Taylor Swift has recounted in song. Anything from new found love, to break ups, to crushes can be found in pop music. But a majority of these will deal with boy/girl relationships. Also found are a lot of party anthems. A feeling of freedom that the wild, drunken parties give the mainstream pop artists seems to be a common subject to write about. (Miley Cyrus, anyone?)
Christian: Again, thousands of love songs exist in christian pop music, as well as some party anthems. But here's the twist. The love songs are about the God/human relationship. (Francesca Battistelli - Forever Love) A few are about human relationships, but God is still present, with the artist thanking Him for the gift of their husband/wife. Party anthems are also drastically different, usually about how thankful the artist is to God that they can be with their friends to just hang out and have some wholesome, pure fellowship. Or about how thankful they are for the small things and how those things just make them want to praise Him. ('Cause it's a Beautiful Day.)
Hip Hop/Rap/Urban:
Now we get into something a little more controversial. These three related genres tend to be self testimonial, with themes of the artists' past, who they are now, and their goals in life.
Mainstream: OK, how many times do we have to hear how hot Mr. Hip Hop star is in his own eyes? Or how he's going to make it big someday, show the world how good he is at making music. Oftentimes we hear stories of how they rose from poverty to taking over a stage and getting a crowd excited over them. It's usually all about self-marketing.
Christian: Nothing too different about the self-testimonial part, but here's the HUGE difference. The artists tend to push God into the forefront. When we hear their stories of where they came from and where they are now, all the credit goes to God and the gifts and blessings He's given them. When they brag about their virtues, they make sure we know it's only because of God that they don't let their pride get the best of them, or the reason they can have that faith that moves mountains. Their life goals are making sure everyone knows how great God is.
Punk Pop/Rock:
Here's a fast paced style that just has the feel of freedom and rebellion in every chord of the grunge guitars.
Mainstream: Fortunately, I've only heard two or three mainstream punk songs. They all generally had the theme of throwing caution to the wind, we'll live forever, to heck with the authority 'cause we are the authority, etc... Nothing more really needs to be said.
Christian: To most folks' surprise, yes, christian punk still has themes of freedom and even rebellion. But here's the fascinating thing. The rebellion is focused on the world, and the lies it constantly besieges our minds with. Christian punk tends to bash the lies down without pulling any punches, throwing truth left and right in an unabashed, up-front way. (Gotta love Hawk Nelson - You Have What I Need! Also Stellar Kart - Innocent). It also celebrates the freedom that the youth have from past mistakes, urging young folk to continue in that purity and live for God, not what people will think of us.
Rock/Metal/Death Metal:
Another contention point. (Also, you did not misread the heading. Yes, I WILL even get into Death Metal.) The blaring guitars, vocals on the verge of screaming, and heavy beats have led many believe that the style is directly from Satan himself. If you have any prejudices, especially on the Death Metal note, please just keep an open mind and hang with me here. I promise it fits. The themes of the rock/metal genre are usually very intense. Intense emotions, situations, and even some subjects that might make the mild mannered squirm.
Mainstream: Rock in this arena tends to be very angry, or show great depression, or even a desire to kill things. Happy thoughts. While general rock shows this in a more nonchalant way, maybe even holding some lighter, profound themes, metal showcases the most intense of emotions. Perhaps, this is the reason for the near screaming. (And even all out screaming depending the subgenre.) Death Metal, on the other hand, has an obsession with Satan, Hell, Death (well, duh), and Demons. I'll just leave it at that.
Christian: Here, rock doesn't really change all that much, thematically. Rock groups such as Third Day and, yes, Switchfoot, explore the more profound thoughts that pop doesn't really accommodate. Metal bands such as Fireflight and Skillet inject more intense emotions into their songs, but with the change of not letting these emotions get the better of them because they know God is strong enough to overcome them. So now... Death Metal... A friend of mine recently told me about her accidental run-in with a Death Metal station. She didn't mean to tune into it, but after a few seconds realized that these were christian bands. She heard lyrics of storming Hell's gates, not letting death win, and even how God will throw Satan down in the end. This is where the theory clicked for me. Even Death Metal holds the same themes when christian bands employ it!
Alright! There you have it! Moving on now!
There is the belief out there that christian musicians are taking over what Satan created and redeeming it for God's glory. But here's the issue with that theory. (I'm getting really excited now!)
1.) In order to redeem something, it has to have belonged to the redeemer in the first place, since redeem means to "buy back". We were created by God, sold ourselves to Satan, and then bought back by Jesus' death. We were redeemed.
2.) Satan is not a creator--repeat! SATAN IS NOT A CREATOR! He is an imitator. He cannot create anything new. He can only take what God has made and pollute it. (Also on that note. Man is not a creator either. Only God can create something new.)
So then, if Satan can't create anything new, and man can't create anything new, then--what if--God created ALL forms of music, along with the themes they hold, and because the church has been wary of anything besides the status quo, the world discovered these styles first, and Satan polluted the themes to glorify himself and sin instead. What if we are merely taking back--truly redeeming what God created, and what Satan tried to imitate?
Sadly, this also brings up another thought. If Satan can't create anything new, (sorry to bring this up so often. It was a new revelation for me, and really makes me happy) then what about when we protest a band for using the style that we attribute to him? By furthering the lie that something was made by Satan, that he has, in fact, managed to create something, we equate his power with that of the true creator, by giving him credit for creating something. Please don't misunderstand me. Give him all the credit for messing up something pure created by God. Call the music that has driven teens to committing suicide his work. That tragedy is on his head, and he will pay for it in the end! But never give him credit for something that only God can do. Frankly, he will never be as powerful as our God, and I'm tired of pretending that he is.
Which now brings us back to Switchfoot. When Jon Foreman handed out water to the protesters (when he had every right to defend his reputation and music) he reminded us that the outward appearance doesn't matter. What matters is the heart. Will there be Switchfoot fans in Hell? None whose heart has been redeemed by Jesus. Will the band Switchfoot be in Hell? Same answer. God is the only one who can truly create a new heart and redeem us, and He chooses/chose to do so no matter how corrupted or polluted our hearts are/were. Now there's an even more amazing thought! I don't know about you, but while the redemption of music excites me, the redemption of the human soul excites me even more!
